top of page

SANGER, HANLEY, SANGER & AVILA
A LIMITED LIABILITY PARTNERSHIP
Santa Barbara, CA
Santa Maria, CA
Sanger, Hanley, Sanger & Avila LLP's Law for People
Criminal Defense & Civil Rights Blog
This blog is not intended as legal advice.
Search
All Posts


Shadow Docket Irony and Executive Control Over First Amendment Rights
There is a certain asynchronous irony about today's shadow docket per curiam opinion. The United States Supreme Court decided Margolin v. National Association of Immigration Judges (No. 26-767) without full briefing and without oral argument.
Robert Sanger
May 262 min read


Shadow Docket Redux
Monday’s, per curiam in District of Columbia v. R.W. 608 U.S. ____ (2026) is yet another example of the use of the shadow docket to decide cases without taking the responsibility of issuing a signed opinion or doing the type of thorough analysis that one would expect from a full opinion after argument.
Robert Sanger
Apr 222 min read


Qualified Immunity in the Shadows
The United States Supreme Court today issued a per curiam opinion from its shadow docket in Zorn v. Linton. The unsigned opinion was met by the dissent of Justice Sotomayor. The issue was whether or not a police officer was entitled to a summary judgment based on qualified immunity. As Justice Sotomayor pointed out, the majority continued its statistical trend to find in favor of police officers In excessive force cases. Both the opinion and the dissent Interpreted lower fede
Robert Sanger
Mar 231 min read


Have You No Shame?
On March 2, 2026, the Office of the Attorney General of the United States agreed to abandon its appeal from the District Court rulings in favor of Perkins Coie and other firms seeking to strike down the Executive Order punishing them. Sanger, Hanley, Sanger & Avila, along with 503 other firms, signed on to an amicus brief supporting the targeted firms who then prevailed in the district court.
Robert Sanger
Mar 42 min read


A Trial Court Order Limiting Communications Between Defendant and Attorney May Be Valid
The United States Supreme Court today, in an opinion by Justice Jackson (Villareal v. Texas, No. 24-557), held that defendants in criminal cases who are on the stand can be restricted from discussing their testimony with their own lawyers during overnight recesses.
Robert Sanger
Feb 252 min read


“Community Caretaker” Exception to The Fourth Amendment
The United States Supreme Court this morning in the case of Case v. Montana (No. 24-624) reaffirmed the “community caretaker” exception to the requirement of a warrant under the Fourth Amendment for entry into a home. Justice Jackson wrote for the majority.
Robert Sanger
Jan 142 min read


Why Don't I Feel Safer?
The Ninth Circuit just issued an Opinion in Baird v. Bonta , No. 24-565 (January 2, 2026) (“ Baird ”) which took an expansive view of the United States Supreme Court decision in New York State Rifle & Pistol Ass’n v. Bruen , 597 U.S. 1 (2022) (“ Bruen ”). Basically, Baird found California’s Open Carry law unconstitutional on its face as it related to counties with populations of 200,000 or more. (It denied an “as applied” challenge to the application of the law to count
Robert Sanger
Jan 42 min read


Addressing Mental Health Needs in Santa Barbara: A Call for Action
At September’s Stepping Up meeting, the Santa Barbara Sheriff’s Office, Behavioral Wellness, and other community stakeholders gathered to discuss ongoing challenges in addressing the mental health needs of jail inmates and the community at large.
Michael Hanley
Sep 19, 20253 min read


Arkansas Death Row Inmates Challenge State’s New Death Penalty Statute
A state’s method of execution is typically challenged under the Eighth Amendment prohibition against cruel and unusual punishment. These...
Sarah Sanger
Sep 8, 20252 min read
bottom of page